Spotify to Kalshi and Polymarket: Remove Our Logo — Traders Pumped Streams to Win a $3M Bet
Spotify identified over 500,000 artificial streams injected into Malcolm Todd's song 'Earrings' to manipulate its US chart position, then sent formal letters on 2 July demanding that Kalshi and Polymarket remove its branding. The manipulation targeted a $3M Kalshi market on the most-streamed song in the US for June. Kalshi had already paid out bettors before the fraud was confirmed.
Spotify identified and removed more than 500,000 artificial streams injected into Malcolm Todd's song 'Earrings,' which had briefly appeared as one of the most-played tracks on its US charts in June. The inflation was not for chart glory — the target was a $3 million Kalshi prediction market on which song would be most streamed in the US that month. Traders who held contracts on 'Earrings' could profit directly from flooding the song with bots, which is exactly what the evidence suggests happened. Kalshi paid out the market on the inflated figures before Spotify confirmed the manipulation.
On 2 July, Spotify sent formal letters to both Kalshi and Polymarket asking each platform to remove its logo and branding from any markets, and to make clear to users that Spotify has no commercial relationship with either exchange. Kalshi has said it is investigating. Neither platform had disclosed a data or licensing agreement with Spotify before this incident.
The underlying mechanics are a textbook oracle-manipulation problem. When the event that settles a market can be influenced by someone who holds a financial position in it, you have created an incentive for manipulation that scales with contract size. A $3 million market on a Spotify chart position is small by World Cup standards, but the economics work: if artificial streams cost less than the contract payout, rational bad actors will attempt it. Kalshi's entertainment markets use third-party data sources as oracles, and the integrity of those sources is now a first-order platform risk.
For UK observers the episode is instructive. The Gambling Commission's long-standing requirement that fixed-odds betting settle on independently verified, manipulation-resistant data is precisely what this incident illustrates the difficulty of. The CFTC's proposed rule, open for comment until 27 July, is built around the concept of 'objective data with integrity infrastructure.' The Spotify incident will feature prominently in the comment letters filed by those who argue prediction markets are structurally closer to gambling than to financial instruments — and that argument now has a vivid, concrete example.
Operators mentioned in this article
Recent updates
Crypto.com and Novig Sue Missouri as Market Leaders Hold Back — Eighth Circuit Now in Play via Iowa
Crypto.com and Novig filed federal lawsuits on October 16 challenging Missouri's cease-and-desist orders, arguing their sports event contracts fall under exclusive CFTC jurisdiction. The suits came as Missouri's 30-day compliance window closed. Notably, the market leaders — Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, and Underdog — have not sued; Missouri said it is in 'ongoing discussions' with Kalshi. The outcome is tied to the Eighth Circuit, now weighing the same question in Kalshi's Iowa appeal — the fourth federal circuit to take up the prediction market question.
Ohio Escalates Post-Sixth Circuit — Cease-and-Desist to 10 Operators, but Platforms Keep Operating
Emboldened by its Sixth Circuit win, Ohio escalated enforcement. Governor Mike DeWine and the Ohio Casino Control Commission issued cease-and-desist letters dated October 2 to 10 operators, including Polymarket and Robinhood, with an October 16 deadline and penalties up to the value gained from contracts. Kalshi was excluded because a court order already covers it. As of October 20, platforms were still operating in Ohio despite the deadline. Polymarket has sued the Commission and AG Andy Wilson; Wilson is expected to sue non-compliant operators.
Midterm Election Betting Tops $220M — Double the Entire 2024 Cycle — as Public Opposition Mounts
Traders have wagered more than $220 million on the 2026 US congressional midterms across Kalshi and Polymarket, more than double the $92 million bet across the entire 2024 cycle, according to a Reuters analysis of Anti-Corruption Data Collective data published October 14. The 2026 cycle has more than 21,000 individual markets, up from 463 in 2024. Volume is concentrated in a few races, led by the Texas Senate contest. The growth comes despite a Reuters/Ipsos poll finding most Americans oppose using prediction markets to bet on elections.